Thursday, July 29, 2021
Home Business Can’t Auction Satellite Spectrum: Terrestrial concept of exclusivity doesn't apply, hence auctioning...

Can’t Auction Satellite Spectrum: Terrestrial concept of exclusivity doesn’t apply, hence auctioning is not applicable


The world over, satellite spectrum is authorised for ‘right-to-use’ by all administrations and is allocated only by administrative process, at charges that essentially cover the cost of administration.

In India, the so-called Radio Spectrum for Mobile Services is an emotive subject, and needless confusion has recently arisen over the allocation of spectrum for satellite communications, including broadcasting.

First, one must understand that spectrum is not a single commodity. Many types are involved—the several varieties of terrestrial spectrum for mobile access or for backhaul or for WiFi, etc, and the non-terrestrial, or satellite, spectrum. These involve completely differing treatments. It is also understandable that, by its very nature, satellite spectrum has no national territorial limits and is international in character and is therefore coordinated and managed by the UN agency, International Telecommunications Union (ITU), Geneva. There is, in fact, a specific treaty in place for spectrum cooperation, and India is a signatory to it.

The satellite systems have to be internationally coordinated as per relevant ITU Regulations, for the satellite networks to operate without harmful interference. Satellite-network operations require bilateral/multilateral coordination and cooperation. It is incumbent on the potential satellite operator (or operating agency) to obtain access to frequency assignments and suitable orbital position.

ITU’s Radio Regulations are based on the principles of `efficient and rational use of the RF spectrum’ and ‘equitable access’ to spectrum/orbit resources for countries, laid down in No. 196 (Article 44) of the ITU Constitution. Resolution 2 of the Radio Regulations provides that “all countries have equal rights in the use of both the radio frequencies allocated to various space radio-communication services and the geostationary-satellite orbit and other satellite orbits for these services.” Resolve 1 of Resolution 2 states that the registration with the Radio-Communication Bureau of frequency assignments for space radio-communication services and their use does not provide any permanent priority to any individual country or groups of countries and does not create an obstacle to the establishment of space systems by other countries. To use a commercial analogy, countries should not see the ITU as a wholesaler of spectrum rights granted in perpetuity, which countries can then market at retail to satellite operators.

The world over, satellite spectrum is authorised for ‘right-to-use’ by all administrations and is allocated only by administrative process, at charges that essentially cover the cost of administration.

Unlike terrestrial spectrum, satellite spectrum is never exclusively assigned to the operator but coordinated internationally and shared among multiple operators for different orbital slots and all types of satellites. Thus, the terrestrial concept of exclusivity does not apply and auctioning therefore is not applicable. Moreover, any commodity to be auctioned has, obviously, to be free from any encumbrances. Satellite spectrum has international encumbrances.

Since inception, in every nation, microwave backhaul spectrum has never been auctioned. If satellite spectrum were to be auctioned, by the same logic and for level playing field, it would entail the taking back of all backhaul microwave spectrum from mobile operators and auctioning them. Similarly, WiFi spectrum which is delicensed the world over and in India, would have to be taken back from operators and the public, and auctioned.

It is interesting that the other camp seeks to invoke level playing field conditions promised by Article14 of the Constitution and also the famous judgement of the SC in the 2G spectrum matter, to demand auction of satellite spectrum. Unfortunately, this is a grossly flawed argument and confirms the opposite. In the cited 2G Spectrum case, there was a Presidential Reference No.1 of 2012, wherein the Supreme Court, opined, in its advisory jurisdiction, that “Auction, as a method of disposal of natural resources, cannot be declared to be a Constitutional mandate under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.” The SC further stated that “Auction may be the best way of maximising revenue, but revenue maximisation may not always be the best way to serve public good.” India has only one-third of its Asian peers’ satellite connectivity per capita and only one-twentieth or even lower than that of Europe and the US. A very poor position for our digital ambitions. We must expeditiously move ahead, in tune with global trends and practices which definitely preclude auction of satellite spectrum.. Policymakers should not allow the commercial vested interests of a few terrestrial incumbents to stall or block the massive potential contributions of the satellite sector.

With research inputs from Debashish Bhattacharya

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, Check out latest IPO News, Best Performing IPOs, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.





Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

4 Guidelines You Can Use To Easily Get More Sales

Sydney has seen unprecedented growth in the number of people doing online transactions. With an estimated 4.34% of the population going in for cashless...

HOW CAN AYURVEDA HELP IN LOWERING BLOOD CHOLESTEROL LEVELS?

High cholesterol levels can stimulate life-threatening diseases. Over time, a plaque build-up on the coronary arteries may lead to restricted heart flow, infection, heart...

Importance of a Property Site Visit in Chennai

Chennai is recognized as one of the fastest-growing cities by the US Forbes magazine. The sustained expansion of the automobile and financial services industry,...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

4 Guidelines You Can Use To Easily Get More Sales

Sydney has seen unprecedented growth in the number of people doing online transactions. With an estimated 4.34% of the population going in for cashless...

HOW CAN AYURVEDA HELP IN LOWERING BLOOD CHOLESTEROL LEVELS?

High cholesterol levels can stimulate life-threatening diseases. Over time, a plaque build-up on the coronary arteries may lead to restricted heart flow, infection, heart...

Importance of a Property Site Visit in Chennai

Chennai is recognized as one of the fastest-growing cities by the US Forbes magazine. The sustained expansion of the automobile and financial services industry,...

Top 10 Hair Transplant in Pune

A hair transplant is a medical procedure used to treat baldness. The hair follicles are taken from the patient’s body and implanted where the...

Recent Comments